I bought these shoes as dress shoes for my 5 year old since i have hear good things about the company and quality- but the rubber soles are coming off the shoes the first time he wore them!!!!!! I am so upset since they are really cute! I contacted Naturino and Amazon to see what can be done.As to sizing since they are loafers I would go a bit small since kids have a harder time keeping loafers on their feet.slightly too narrow tho. and they came in solid blue when i was expecting the multi colored design like in the picture. i like them anyway and so does my son so we kept them.This loafer looks so good in person. Very soft leather with nice thick cushion padding. Not only that I love this shoes but my 3 year-old like it so much that he wear them around the house. I'm going to order another color in a bigger size (for my son to grow into) after writing this review.I love to dress my toddler but he has chubby feet so its been hard finding him loafers that fit so this is the first pair that fit his chubby feets perfectly iam so happy I will be buying this brand diff colors because the shoe looks so cute .... :)These shoes are so cute and fashionable. Not to mention the cushioned footbed and the elastic around the top to give it a snug fit for busy toddlers.Highly recommend and especially for the sale price!!they fit my son perfectly (his foot is wide) and are absolutely adorable! I also paid a great price for them which is one of the best parts :)Love these shoe .. Very soft and comfortable my son loves to wear them all the time love them def suggest these shoe