These are a quality boot. They are made from a decent leather like material that doesn't feel cheap and doesn't just peel right off. The bottoms are rugged and help greatly with traction. My main issue, they are a bit too high for my daughter. She is almost 4 years old and I ordered a size 10 which is one size bigger than what currently fits. When we slid these new boots on, they actually covered over her knee, but they aren't designed to be worn over the knee, because the back of the boot is solid and can't bend. So, as she walks, she looks a bit like a robot and I imagine that she may get blisters. I'll have to wait until she grows a couple more inches before I'm comfortable really letting her wear them. Hopefully she doesn't outgrow the size of the boot before the height matches up. I'd tell the seller to shorten the boot by at least and an if not two or three. Perhaps my daughter just has short legs, but I've never had issues with any other riding boot.I got these for my son to complete his "jedi" costume. The price and looks were just what we were looking for. When he tried them on he loved them, but my oldest daughter saw the pink box (that I was doing my best to hide) and blurted out "ARE THOSE GIRL SHOES?!" while I tried to shush her. Fortunately he was so involved in the awesomeness of the boots that he didn't hear her. He says they are really comfortable, but hard to zip (I think the pleather is a little stiff) I imagine the zipper loosens up with time. He really likes them and when he is finished with them I will give them to my niece, she rides horses so she will also love them.I have to clarify that the product was beautiful, the only problem was the shoe size. I guess my daughter had a growth spurt and I hadn't realized it, so I ordered her a size 4, which was too small. The only reason why I'm giving a 4 star is because amazon didn't have a larger size in stock. It was pretty upsetting because I really loved these boots.These Nina boots look very classic and smart on my granddaughter, they seemed to fit very well. The color is perfect. They look like they will last until she grows out of them. I was happy I could fine them on Amazonsmile. Thank you for the opportunity to tell everyone about these magnificent boots!I was quite happy with this boot for my 5 year old, the color and quality are good. The only improvment could be made with the zipper, it is difficult to pull up at times and she does need help getting in and out of them becuase of this.I bought these for my little girls Fall/Winter Outfits and they are great! Pretty well made, considereing theyre not real leather. They are quite tall, so they may not work so well on tiny or shorter little ones. She really likes them, but because 5 year olds tend to play hard, I make sure to keep them free of dust and debris, and I rub a bit of vaseline on the toes and heel to prevent them from getting to scratched up. So far, so good! Only wish they had them in my size!Super cute boots they seemed to be true to size. The zipper quality is not that great however my granddaughter adores the look of the boot and I will keep since they are so stylish.I would recommend to purchase!These are exactly what we were looking for! They are stylish but very comfortable. My 8 year old wears them almost daily. I think they will hold up for a long time. I wish they had them in my size. They look just like the picture. I feel they are way better quality, and look better than something you would buy at like Target or Old Navy. It is truly a case of you get what you pay for.