She has not worn these in a game yet, but I am reviewing based on appearance and size. She wears an 8.5 in toddler shoes, so based on the reviews I bought these in both 9 and a 10, figuring I could return whichever one did not fit. Many other reviewer's recommended going a size up, but in our case they fit very true to size. She is just starting to fit loosely into a toddler 9, and that is how this 9 fits. Will definitely take her through the season, and they are very cute so I'll probably just keep the next size up for next season. They are a good price and seem to be a very good quality.