My shoe looks like it was returned.Anyways, I was super excited about this shoe, as it's been raved to be comfortable and wide. I don't doubt that these would be comfortable, as they look well made. Unfortunately it was bit long on my 5 yo and too snug on the top of her foot. One side was more tight that she refused to even put it on. With the extra insole, the length was better, but of course way too tight in the front.And like one review said, the white inside lining shows, so kinda unattractive without socks. But less noticeable with socks.Love, love, love these! Last year my kids complained about there uniform shoes all the time. Got these this year and haven’t heard a word from them. They’re super cute, apparently super comfortable (zero complaints which is a miracle), and after three months of almost everyday wear, still look new! Best uniform shoes! I used pedipeds size chart on their website. Ordered exact size after measuring with their sizer and fit perfect!This is the seventh or eighth pair of Pediped Mary Janes we have bought for our daughters. We have had both the Estella and the Naomi in several colors. These are the ONLY kids shoes we have ever purchased that don't wear out before they are outgrown. They stay together and look beautiful from the first day to the last. They look like dress shoes, but they are absolutely sneaker-like in their comfort, flexibility and durability. My girls wear them for everyday wear, even during gym class and at the playground, just as they would their sneakers. Price-wise they are not cheap, but if you can spare a little extra money, these shoes are well worth it for their quality and longevity.My picky daughter absolutely loves these shoes. She is 6 1/2 years old and I got her the size 13. They are perfect for private school uniforms. She's very active on the playground and these are holding up great! She complains about most shoes, but not these! I will be purchasing these again when she out grows this pair.I've purchased these shoes 3 times in different sizes over the past 3 years. These look nice and they do not get ruined when kids scuff them. She has other shoes including Sperry and Balleto flats that the color "chips" off as soon as they are scuffed (usually the first wear).My daughter also has narrow feet so the strap and extra liner they include helps make them more snug and they fit longer.I've also purchased the boot version of this shoe and those were just as good.I just adore these shoes! This is my second time buying them since my daughter outgrew her old ones. I love the addition insole that allows her to get longer wear time and they must be very comfortable because she generally don't like shoes and always complaining that they hurt which I have not heard once since I bought these. Plus they're adorable! A nice spin on the traditional Mary Jane's! Love love loveBoth our girls had these shoes last year and wore them almost every Sunday to church. They look so cute with tights and dresses and I love that they aren't like all the same old boring black shoes out there. They held up great and look hardly worn. Adorable, healthy for growing feet, flex liners make it like 2 shoes in one - I could go on and one about how great these are. Probably the best way to sum it up is to say that we just ordered 2 new pairs for this year! :) Love, love, love these shoes!Great shoes. If you want shoes that hold up through everyday use, dirt, playgrounds, puddles . . These are the shoes!!!!. Both of my girls have them and wear them everyday to school. They are both extremely active and hard on their clothes and shoes. They look exactly like the day they arrived. I am really tired of shoes that look old after the first week. I am glad I bought these.Love pediped shoes as my daughter wears orthotics and these are some of the few shoes that will accommodate them. Good quality as always and look great. Just wish they did them in bigger sizes for next term!Comfortable and flexibleSoft leather insideBold wine colorexcellent buyLove them.Bought many times thumbs up