I have Bogs arcata boots and I love them. I decided to order these for my daughters, who typically wear the tall classic kids winter bog boots. They run a little big in length, but pretty true to size. The reason why only 3 stars is that they are SUPER wide, and the rubber of the top part of the boot is very flexible where it meets the sole. When my daughter walked around in these you could see the shoe deform as she walked, in her words they were very “wobbly”, even with thick socks on. The elastic laces were not able to be tightened appropriately at the bottom. I think this shoe would be better with real laces, as my arcata boots have. I guess we will be sticking to the classic tall Bogs boots as before. I love the Bogs brand, but they missed the mark on this shoe.Sooo soft! Very warm. Comfortable. My 10 year old daughter wears them just hanging out in the house :)