I am a female with short wide feet (D width), and women's boots and shoes are always too narrow, so I shop in the boys department when it comes to footwear. I ordered a pair of these about 8 months ago. Overall, a decent pair of boots for the money. They were comfortable and fit perfectly. (Size 5). I wear them daily around my small farm, and they did keep my feet dry for several weeks until the waterproofing began to wear off. The only really negative thing I didn't like was that the insert came out of one on the first day I wore them, and the other one came out a few days later. Once they came loose, they would not stay in place when put back in, so got rid of those inserts and bought a $2 pair of Dr. Scholls foam inserts, trimmed them and put them in the boots, They stayed in place and made the boots additionally comfy! Last week one boot started to separate from the sole, so I ordered a new pair and just got them. I figure, for the price, 8 months of daily wear is pretty good. I will continue to reorder them as I need them, as long they are available.